The Wright Choice Insurance Group

Small Town Values, Big Time Insurance Solutions

At our agency, we’re more than just insurance providers—we’re your neighbors. Whether you need personal insurance in Columbia, CT or business coverage that protects what you’ve built, we’re here to help. With over 50 years of combined experience, our team makes insurance simple, understandable, and tailored to your needs.

Your Locally Trusted Independent Insurance Agency in Columbia, Connecticut

Finding the right insurance shouldn’t be complicated—it should feel like the right choice. That’s where we come in. At our local, independent insurance agency, we help individuals, families, and businesses across Connecticut get the coverage they need, with the personal service they deserve. From home and auto insurance to business and general liability coverage, our team makes insurance easy to understand. No confusing jargon, no one-size-fits-all policies—just real conversations and real solutions.

Insurance Solutions Built for You.

A black and white drawing of a shield with a person 's face inside of it.

Personal Insurance

You’ve worked hard for what you have—let’s make sure it’s covered.


  • Home Insurance
  • Auto Insurance
  • Umbrella Insurance
  • Renters Insurance

Business Insurance

A black and white drawing of a briefcase and an umbrella.

Running a business comes with risks—we help you manage them.


  • General Liability Insurance
  • Errors & Omissions Insurance
  • Commercial Umbrella Insurance
  • Industry-Specific Insurance



The Independent Advantage

Why Choose Us? – A Team You Can Rely On

Built from the ground up—literally. The Wright Choice Insurance Group, LLC started in a log cabin in 2020, with a mission to provide small-town, neighborly service with big-time expertise. Led by Peggy Wright and a team of experienced insurance professionals, we’ve spent decades helping Connecticut families and businesses find the right coverage at the right price.


✔ Local & Family-Oriented – We offer a range of insurance solutions from top-rated carriers.
✔ Honest & Transparent – We break down policies so you can make informed decisions.
✔ Deeply Rooted in the Community – We live here, work here, and care about our neighbors.

A row of black stars on a white background.

Testimonials

Hear From Families

Like Yours

A wooden house with a window in the middle of a field

Insurance Made Simple, Service You Can Trust

Looking for the right coverage? We’ve got you covered!

See what makes us different from the rest:

A man and a woman are standing in a field with a tree in the background.
A black and white drawing of a hand holding a rope.

Small-Town Service, Big-Time Support

We believe in relationships, not transactions.

A black and white icon of two speech bubbles on a white background.

Independent & Client-Focused

We work for you, not the insurance companies.

A black and white icon of a gear and a check mark.

Customized Insurance Plans

One size doesn’t fit all. We tailor coverage to your needs.

A black and white drawing of a star on a white background.

Decades of Experience

Over 50 years of combined expertise protecting Connecticut residents.

Check Out Our Recent Insights & Tips

How to Find the Best Home Insurance in Connecticut

How to Find the Best Home Insurance in Connecticut

Read more
Understanding Personal Insurance: What You Need to Know

Understanding Personal Insurance: What You Need to Know

Read more
Mastering Personal Property Inventory Easily

Mastering Personal Property Inventory Easily

Read more
Understanding the Rise in Insurance Rates

Understanding the Rise in Insurance Rates

Read more
View more